Connect with us

Entertainment

‘Kesari Chapter 2’ movie review: Akshay Kumar hammers history in this lopsided period piece

Published

on

‘Kesari Chapter 2’ movie review: Akshay Kumar hammers history in this lopsided period piece


Akshay Kumar in ‘Kesari Chapter 2’

Bollywood is going through a ‘sorry’ phase. Last week, in Jaat, Sunny Deol sought an apology from a Sri Lankan extremist. This week, it is the turn of Akshay Kumar to demand an apology from the British government for the Jallianwala Bagh massacre.

While the former was an outright piece of fiction, director and co-writer Karan Singh Tyagi takes excessive creative liberty with history to manufacture nationalist sentiment and a hero. 

It seems that after playing with ancient history, the big boys of Bollywood are meddling with modern history. While the dastardly act of the Empire needs to be exposed, the film, produced by Dharma Productions, milks the sacrifice of martyrs in Jallianwala Bagh to create a trumped-up narrative around the tragic episode.

The disclaimer says it is a piece of fiction, but, as it turns out, it uses real incidents and characters to distort well-documented historical incidents that are easily available at the press of a button.

A primary student of history will brush it off, but the young viewers sitting next to me, who were confused between Dandi and the Salt March, were cheering the courtroom drama. It is hard to expect them to distinguish between General Reginald Dyer and Lieutenant Governor of Punjab Michael O’Dwyer. Akshay seems to be addressing this kind of audience, who are desperate to thump their chest; context doesn’t matter. God is not in the detail here.

It allows Akshay to change get-ups like a fancy dress show. He may be well-meaning and gives it his all, but his focus on quantity is diluting the quality of his cinema. This week, he plays C. Sankaran Nair, a prominent jurist who worked for the Crown and was bestowed with knighthood for his services. He resigned from the Viceroy’s Executive Council after the Jallianwala massacre and held Michael O’Dwyer responsible for the genocide in his book Gandhi and Anarchy. O’Dwyer filed a defamation case against him in the London High Court. The film was expected to be an account of the case that made headlines all over the world and exposed the Empire’s atrocities against its subjects.

However, Tyagi mixes up facts to create a case against General Dyer, the butcher of Jallianwala Bagh in India. Strangely, after promising to expose the larger conspiracy, the film sticks to the obvious villain. Nair suggested that he was just a puppet in the hands of the Lieutenant Governor, but the film fails to convey the bigger picture. There was a reason that Udham Singh targeted O’Dwyer. 

Kesari: Chapter 2 (Hindi)

Director: Karan Singh Tyagi

Cast: Akshay Kumar, R. Madhavan, Ananya Panday, Amit Sial

Run-time: 134 minutes

Storyline: A dramatisation of advocate C. Sankaran Nair’s efforts to bring out the truth behind the Jallianwala Bagh massacre

It talks of sensitivity, but turns English political theorist and economist Harold Laski, one of the jury members who voted in favour of Nair, into Laksi. The English actors, led by Simon Paisley Dey as General Dyer, come across as caricatures speaking long Hindi dialogue in a stilted fashion.

Nair, who was the president of the Indian National Congress in its infancy when the party pursued the policy of prayer and petition, advocated constitutional liberalism and criticised Mahatma Gandhi’s radical nonviolence in his book. Instead of focusing on the complexity of the character and the political activism of the times, Tyagi turns Akshay into the rowdy lawyer of Jolly LLB who resorts to cuss words in court when he runs out of legal jargon. The CBFC, which asks for references when reviewing films made on historical characters and events, seems to have given a long rope after awarding the ‘A’ certificate. 

It starts with Akshay talking kanoon and Kathakali, but since the makers had to establish a link with Kesari and Akshay’s real-life persona, the Malayali advocate’s soul song remains unchanged, and we get to hear “Main Mitti Main Mil Jaavan” in the background. Saddled with a sketchily written character, R. Madhavan repeats himself as the genius suffering from jealousy, and Ananya Panday seems to have been dressed up for a period fashion shoot.

The camera captures the massacre with the intent to provoke and set the stage for an enraged Akshay. Tyagi gets so engrossed in serving his star that the storytelling goes for a toss. He makes no effort to track the backstory behind the massacre. The Rowlatt Act remains out of conversation, the fact that the British were baffled by the Hindu-Muslim unity on Ram Navami gets just a passing reference, and there is no mention of the Hunter Commission.

If you are done with chest-thumping, check out Ram Madhvani’s recent OTT series on the subject. It is also a piece of fiction, but it feels closer to the truth.



Source link

Entertainment

Kyrgyz filmmaker Dastan Zhapar on his first independent work Deal at the Border

Published

on

Kyrgyz filmmaker Dastan Zhapar on his first independent work Deal at the Border


Shankar M K

Kyrgyz filmmaker Dastan Zhapar’s work is a profound meditation on his society’s shifting relationship with the past and the evolving landscape of Kyrgyzstan’s traditions. At the heart of his cinematic exploration is death, through which he examines societal ruptures and continuities, and reimagines a future.

Kyrgyz society, like other societies previously part of the Soviet Union, has had to deal with three traditions — pre-Soviet, Soviet socialist, and contemporary.

Dastan made A Father’s Will in 2016 and Road to Eden in 2020, both in collaboration with fellow filmmaker Bakyt Mukul. A Father’s Will won the Golden Zenith at the 40th Montreal World Film Festival. Deal at the Border, screened at the recent Bangalore International Film Festival, is Zhapar’s first independent work.

While A Father’s Will was about how reviving an old death ritual helped pacify people defrauded by a man now deceased, Road to Eden reflected on the loss of meaning caused by material compulsions of modern life. With Deal at the Border, Dastan turns to even darker realities — modern slavery and human rights issues. Death here becomes a moment of moral reckoning.

As an amorphous repository of attitudes, practices, and relational hierarchies, a tradition never truly dies. In Dastan’s films, two traditions reside within the present — struggling for attention and validation. The resonances of this exploration are impossible to miss in India, bogged down by a similar contest between putative traditions.

Kyrgyz filmmaker Dastan Zhapar
| Photo Credit:
Special Arrangement

In an exclusive, Dastan shares his thoughts on the many issues of idea, ideology and creative expression. Excerpts:


Why is it that you question some traditions and try to restore respect for others?

It is true that I am questioning some traditions, but I am not seeking to restore respect for others. Things emerge in the process of scripting and filming. They beg to be projected on the screen and I am persuaded by this kind of insight.


Death and how people respond to it seems to be a common theme in all your films.

That is right. However, it was not by conscious design — it turned out that way. Death occupied centrestage and spliced three of my films into an unintended trilogy. However, the ideas I am now working on are about survival and the desire for freedom.

A Father’s Will plays out an aspect of the Kyrgyz attitude to death. People at a burial desire closure. They want to accept and forgive. Also, they like to ask what kind of a person the deceased was as a prelude to restoring dignity to the dead. These rituals serve to unite people, especially family, in times of sorrow.

Kyrgyz filmmaker Dastan Zhapar during a shoot

Kyrgyz filmmaker Dastan Zhapar during a shoot
| Photo Credit:
Special Arrangement


Why is the yurt (a portable, circular dwelling, traditionally used by nomadic people in Central Asia) so important?

The Kyrgyz had a nomadic, mobile way of life. The yurt naturally became home and a symbol of family stability. It also represents the strength of the national collective, serving a material function and as a spiritual metaphor.

A Father’s Will turns out to be based on a book written by a character in The Road to Eden

When Bakyt Mukul and I wrote the script for A Father’s Will, we thought it would be nice to have a literary work associated with the film’s story. When we were scripting for The Road to Eden, and came up with the image of the sick writer Sapar, we thought he could write, for example, a book titled The Father’s Testament referring to our previous film. In this way, we would have an imaginary author for an imaginary book on which our first film had been based. In this fashion, we were able to thematically unite the two films. The stories take place in the same universe, same ethical ecosystem.

Kyrgyz filmmaker Dastan Zhapar

Kyrgyz filmmaker Dastan Zhapar
| Photo Credit:
Special Arrangement


What is your next film about?

I am actively working on three ideas. One is the story of guards at the border of Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan. Another is about modern slavery.


Why is slavery a subtext of Deal at the Border?

Slavery has been on my mind for a long time as I have been personally affected by it. My brother Aktan was enslaved in a neighbouring country with our uncle. Luckily, they managed to escape. The script was written by Aktan and I.

While writing the script, I studied modern slavery. I learnt that Kyrgyzstan ranks first among Central Asian countries whose citizens are enslaved abroad, mostly in Kazakhstan, Russia, Turkey and the UAE. According to the International Labour Organisation, more than 50 million people are currently enslaved worldwide and 70% of them are women. These statistics are horrifying. We must bring this to the notice of viewers everywhere.

Kyrgyz filmmaker Dastan Zhapar during a shoot

Kyrgyz filmmaker Dastan Zhapar during a shoot
| Photo Credit:
Special Arrangement


From what sources do you draw inspiration from?

Definitely from the Kyrgyz epic of Manas. It is a poem with more than 1,50,000 verses. It is about the legendary past of many nations of Central Asia, including the Mongol, Kitai, and Altai.

Newspaper reports often provide a starting point for an episode. I am also inspired by themes other directors explore. The most important thing is to select the right theme or story. The story must resonate in you. It must refer to some piece of today’s reality or to a possible state of affairs in the future.

I prefer to make films about the rural and remote regions, though cities have their stories too. I ride the bus and observe people as they travel and converse. I can learn much about their troubles and what makes them happy. I dig into real life material so I can use them in my films.


What are your thoughts on Indian cinema?

I am in awe of Indian films screened at international film festivals — they deal with serious issues in interesting ways. I would like to be involved in a joint venture with India sometime in the future. The first Kyrgyz feature film was made in 1958, by which time Indian cinema was already in bloom.

Kyrgyz filmmaker Dastan Zhapar during a shoot

Kyrgyz filmmaker Dastan Zhapar during a shoot
| Photo Credit:
Special Arrangement


Are you responding to any particular filmmaking tradition?

I like the image of Duishen, the teacher created by Kyrgyz author Chingiz Aitmatov in his novel First Teacher that was later made into a film. Duishen brings knowledge and knowledge is light, pulling millions of people out of the darkness of ignorance. Duishen had a fanatic faith in a bright future ushered in by literacy and education. Eventually that is what led mankind to seemingly impossible things such as space exploration. I believe such people are in short supply in our crazy world today.



Source link

Continue Reading

Entertainment

The Cecilian Choir, from Bengaluru, raises its voice for a cause

Published

on

The Cecilian Choir, from Bengaluru, raises its voice for a cause


One of Bengaluru’s oldest choirs, The Cecilian Choir, will perform for a fundraiser in Bengaluru. Titled Memories Are Made of This, it is a fundraiser for St. Joseph’s University Scholarship Programs. The Cecilian Choir was started in 1982 by a group of musicians under the leadership of Reverend Dr Theodore Pereira.  

This year, the concert will be held at St. Joseph’s Auditorium, and offers financial assistance to students who come from economically weaker sections of society, says Arthur B Pais, President, Cecilian Choir.

The choir, he says, has been around for 42 years. “We are probably the longest serving choir in Bengaluru and intend to keep this legacy going. All our stage performances are fundraisers.”

Arthur describes each of the choir’s fundraisers as a worthy cause and over the years Cecilian Choir has helped raised funds for Multiple Sclerosis Society, Maria Seva Sangha, Abala Ashraya Sangha, Atma Shakti Vidayala Society, The Karunashraya Hospice, St Mary’s Orphanage, Sumanahalli Leprosy Rehabilitation Centre, The Association of People with Disability and Jeevarathani Foundation.

“In fact, when Karunahsraya started, we helped raise funds for their infrastructure. The concert was held at Guru Nanak Bhavan,” recalls Arthur.

Besides these, Arthur says some of their memorable performances include the 1999 concert at the invitation of Ministry of Tourism, Israel to perform at the Sherovah Theatre in Jerusalem and at a monastery in Nazareth for the millennium celebrations; and the 2011 concert presented by Indian Council of Cultural Relations (ICCR) and the Bangalore School of Music (BSM); in the presence of the ex-President of India, Pratibha Patil.

“We were the only Choir to have ever sung a song in Kannada at the Rashtrapati Bhavan,” shares the chorister.

Arthur B Pais, President, Cecilian Choir
| Photo Credit:
Special Arrangement

St Joseph’s University, Arthur says, help students with excellent academic records, high achievers, and differently-abled students. “The university also has study and residential scholarships, besides giving them midday meals, which most of the time, is the only meal some students get due to their financial situation. That’s who we are singing for.”

The first half of the concert, Arthur says, will feature music across eight decades. “There will be a Broadway musical medley, jazz, ballads and masterpieces, some of which, will be a cappella. The second half includes ‘Remember the Cross’ an Easter Cantata that intertwines songs from Palm Sunday to Easter Sunday in a blended and contemporary setting”.

The choir will be conducted by Deirdre Fernandes-Dominic and will have Rebecca Thomas-Colaco (piano), Justin A Santosh (drums), Eric Samuel (guitar), Pearl Mukadam (bass), Darren Sherwin and Sabarish R (keyboards) and 25 choristers.

Sing in harmony, Arthur said the choir is nothing like a band performance. “We are a choir and sing in multi-part harmony, which could be either a three, four, six or eight-part. When we say ‘harmony’, I strongly believe one has to experience it to know how a voice can modulate itself and give you different tones, which leads to a fantastic experience.”

Arthur is a first tenor, and has been singing with the since 2000. “Becky, (Rebecca) has been with us since 2005. She is a reputed pianist, known world-wide and now is the director of faculty too with BSM (Bangalore School of Music).”

A self taught singer, Arthur took to music as a young boy and started singing in his church choir. “That is where you get noticed by conductors and are picked up for choral singing. For me, choral singing came naturally and I found it easy to pick it up.”

The concert is on April 26 and 27, at 3.30pm and 6.30pm at St Joseph’s University Auditorium, 36 Lalbagh Road. Donor passes/tickets on BookMyShow.



Source link

Continue Reading

Entertainment

And we are off at warp speed

Published

on

And we are off at warp speed


A still from season 2 of ‘Andor’
| Photo Credit: JioHotstar

One of the clever things Tony Gilroy has done (and he has done many with this extraordinary show) with Andoris in the name. When you name a show after a character, you expect it to be about that character. And while Andor is about Cassian Andor (Diego Luna), the petty thief who sacrificed himself for the Rebel Alliance, it also follows the arcs of the characters in the periphery, making us invested in them.

Andor season 2 (English)

Episodes: 3

Runtime: 44 – 53 minutes

Creator: Tony Gilroy

Starring: Diego Luna, Kyle Soller, Adria Arjona, Stellan Skarsgård, Genevieve O’Reilly, Denise Gough, Faye Marsay, Varada Sethu, Elizabeth Dulau

Storyline: A theft, a kidnapping, a betrayal, an unlikely relationship, a secret assignment and a wedding

A prequel to 2016’s Rogue One, which Gilroy wrote with Chris Weitz, the series follows Cassian’s transformation from selfish hustler to selfless martyr. Andor stood out among all the Star Wars shows for its accessibility. By focusing on robust storytelling rather than hoping for the Skywalkers, Jedi or the Force to bail them out, Andor zoomed to the stratosphere quite like one of those tie fighters in our favourite galaxy far, far away.

Andor is set five years before the events of Rogue One, which in turn is set a week before Star Wars: A New Hope, and tells of the efforts of the Rebel Alliance to steal the plans of the Death Star. Season 1 followed a year in Cassian’s life, which he begins by skulking around Ferrix and ends up working for the mysterious recruiter, Luthen Rael (Stellan Skarsgård).

Season 1 ended with the droids assembling the Death Star from the work of the prisoners on Narkina 5, and also with Ferrix rising up against the Empire. Season 2 opens a year later with Cassian following the Star Wars tradition of stealing an imperial craft after telling a technician who is helping him, “you have become more than your fear, let that protect you”, revealing the blossoming of his leadership qualities.

We learn what has happened to the others in Andor’s orbit. Bix (Adria Arjona), who was tortured (one cannot imagine what the dying children on Dizon Fray sounded like), still has terrible dreams even when she is far away from Ferrix and with friends including Brasso (Joplin Sibtain).

The fiercely ambitious Dedra Meero (Denise Gough) of the Imperial Security Bureau (ISB) has to put her plans to find Axis on hold as Orson Krennic (Ben Mendelsohn) has her on a black op. Syril Karn (Kyle Soller), who saved Dedra from the riot on Ferrix, is now in Bureau of Standards and in a relationship with Dedra.

There is a wedding in Chandrila between imperial senator, Mon Mothma’s (Genevieve O’Reilly) daughter Leida, and the son of a shady businessman, Davo Sculdun. The first three episodes zip by at warp speed, elegantly cutting between the glittering wedding preparations, Cassian’s desperate escape from rebel fighters who do not recognise him, the ISB’s black op, the arbitrary census undertaken by the Empire and a visit from Syril’s mother, Eedy (Kathryn Hunter).

The clothes are lovely. Leida’s wedding dress is a vision in white, Dedra’s loungewear reveals a softer side to a woman who has to fight every inch of her way, Luthen’s asymmetrical coats say a lot about the man while Mon’s impeccably cut outfits are an extra layer of armour in the double life she is leading. The worlds — from golden farms to snowy holdfasts, gracious Chandrilan buildings to riotous forests are splendid islands of wonder.

There are parallels to the real world, with illegal workers being hunted even though they are needed for the harvest, gouge mining rendering a planet’s core unstable, and the Ferrixian gong, which underlines how insignificant individuals are in the faceless might of the Empire.

There are some creatures, including that almost cow at the farm and some at the wedding, but not so many that they overwhelm the very human story.

With each batch of three episodes covering a year, and the final three covering the three days before Rogue One, which means in another part of the galaxy, Princess Leia has been kidnapped by the respiratorily-challenged Lord Vader, Gilroy has us well and truly hooked.

Andor season 2 is currently streaming on JioHotstar.



Source link

Continue Reading

Trending

Copyright © 2025 Republic Diary. All rights reserved.